Picard favors justice for Wesley over the Prime Directive. This must be stated: The Prime Directive literally means you can’t move against the Nazis, no matter what they do, short of attacking you. The Prime Directive is a plot device cooked up by a patently optimistic TV writer (either Trek producer Gene L. Coon or writer Theodore Sturgeon, depending on who you ask) in the mid-1960s. Charity and nonprofits provide relief efforts and help governments respond to devastating health problems like HIV, Polio and Malaria. By the end of the episode, Picard refuses to help repair ships needed for the drug-dealing to take place, also citing the Prime Directive. Trump's Budget Is Immoral Bernie Sanders The budget introduced this week by the Trump administration constitutes nothing less than a massive transfer of wealth from working families, the elderly, children, the sick and the poor to the top 1%. Life, liberty, and property are certainly worthy candidates of a political Prime Directive for Christians. In short, one world consists entirely of rich drug dealers, and the other world drug addicts hopelessly dependent upon them. What about, say, Japan, in which the end of isolation and the start of modernization lead to a ferocious war machine? Not the convention-going sort, but I loved TNG and some of the subsequent series as well. It seems to be the case when he is upholding some other ideal equally detached from human suffering, or when it impacts him personally. The Prime Directive is overridden by: * Omega Directive (Top Secret) * General Order 24 Furthermore, Federation Citizens are not bound to the Prime Directive. In the future, there is no hunger, war, or poverty. The suffering and exploitation of millions of people is simply not his problem. It seems he’d rather let slavish devotion to an abstract ideal decide them. TechRepublic Premium: The best IT policies, templates, and tools, for today and tomorrow. The purpose of the Prime Directive is to assure that a retrospective has the right culture to make it a positive and result oriented event. On the surface, it sounds like a good idea: don’t screw around with other cultures. After Dr. Crusher tells the captain that it would be relatively easy to ease the population -of millions- off of the drug, Picard is not moved to intervene, citing the Prime Directive. A “Prime Directive” would forbid all of this (and in the Trek universe, has done so). Besides, if you've got all this advanced knowledge and tech, how do you make episodes where the crew encounters less-developed alien societies interesting, when the Trekkers could simply overmatch them? Why not prevent them from being exploited ala Bajor? Well, I guess it sucks to be anyone else on that planet who shall perish because they don’t have a radio. The Prime Directive of the church is laid out in the Great Commission. TNG really shines in moments as a sci-fi Aesop’s fables where virtues and ideals are compared and explored. Providing knowledge … The Prime Directive was implemented precisely because in previous instance of cross-species interaction, it was considered "unethical" not to try to interfere and uplift them. Having been told by Data that the planet will be “uninhabitable within 38 hours” meaning, everyone dies, Picard gives instructions to Worf, who is going to investigate Nikolai’s apparent disappearance. Simple: You put a plot device in place that forces Starfleet not to use their technical advantages in the presence of beings that have not achieved such levels of advancement--effectively forcing the characters to fight with one arm tied behind their backs and think their way out of problems. It's a freshmen-year philosophy student's reaction to the Cold War, when America and the Soviets were playing out their hostilities by proxy third-world conflicts. Ditto for untold thousands or millions on Boraal II. Maybe Picard’s certainty that it is “a philosophy and a very correct one” is a bit stronger than it ought to be. One appeared to recover from the plague, and also began selling a “treatment” to the other which turned out to be an addictive narcotic. Read his full profile. It is granted that every law has mitigating circumstances and there are exceptions to every rule, but maybe if your rule needs 14 classes of exceptions, it’s a bit too simple and naive to hold as “general order number 1”. But that’s okay, they’ll all die martyrs for the ideal of justice. and. He violates it, usually without remark, here, here, and notably, here, where Kirk gives his interpretation of the Prime Directive that allows him to apply it rather loosely: “…the Prime Directive was intended to apply only to living, growing civilizations and felt it was appropriate to interfere where societies had been enslaved or were in a state of total stagnation.” (source Memory Alpha). Where should our aid go? Category: Critical Thinking • Featured Inc • philosophy • skepticism. The Picard quote at the top comes from a season 1 episode called Symbiosis. The Picard quote at the top comes from a season 1 episode called Symbiosis. Picard answers, quite honestly, that he’ll not let arithmetic answer those questions. Effectively, they were interfering in the "development" of underprivileged countries to further their own ends with some awful immediate and long-term results. Then Picard will save you. The story pertains to two worlds in which both were ravaged by a plague in the distant past. In the film Nemesis, which ends the TNG saga, all pretense to concern for the Prime Directive is gone, because dune buggies are fun: The list of Picard’s obtuse, stochastic treatments of the Prime Directive is long and this post is long enough. The Prime Directive is merely a familiar example of the universal tension between highly general moral ideals and real-world applications. Picard is often a psychotic ideologue when it comes to the Prime Directive, which makes his frequent breaks with it worth a closer look. In The Drumhead, a Star Fleet Admiral notes that Picard has violated the Prime Directive nine times in just three years. He changes his mind only after inadvertently hearing her plea for help. Picard waves this off with a remark about justifiable “circumstances”. Even non-warp civilizations are likely to be visited by non-federation space-faring societies, thus contaminating them anyway. Pakistan has blocked access to five dating apps for their delivery of "immoral/indecent content" in the majority-Muslim nation. Lt. Worf’s brother Nikolai, in a rogue action, moves to save a village of a couple hundred people. Generally speaking, those situations will be rarer than the instances where interference in a primitive culture results in an unforeseen evil. the following indictment of Star Trek's vaunted Prime Directive.